Pixies

A Pixies Poll



A PIXIES POLL last update: June 23rd 1998 (500 contributions, +125 since last update)

This living poll was initiated in February 1995, and is regularly updated on the basis of new contributions.

If you wish to contribute to this poll, try to answer some or all of the following questions, and drop us a note (chris@aleceiffel.net) with your answers, or just click HERE for a beautiful form!

Please, try not to read the results before you make up your mind, as it may biase your answer (or just check you didn't forget a song!).

Here are the 3 questions:

  1. What are your favorite Pixies songs? If possible, list them in your preference order, and try to limit your selection to 10 songs maximum.
  2. Rank Pixies albums from your most to your least prefered. You can either couple or separate Surfer Rosa and Come On Pilgrim.
  3. Rank Pixies, Frank Black, and the Breeders. The interest of this question is mainly to know whether Pixies fans prefer one or the other of Pixies legacy.
When the poll was initiated, the Amps (K. Deal) and the Martinis (J. Santiago) didn't exist yet. Feel free to include them in the answer.

PIXIES SONGS 496 votes

For each song is given its origin(s):

10 points when the song was ranked 1st, then 9, 8, and so on.
5 points to each song when no order given
1 point to each "extra" song (when 10 were not enough)

Rank Title (Origin) Points (nb times ranked 1st/nb times listed)
1 (=) Debaser (DOO+DttP+BSI) 1745 (48/257)
2 (=) Where Is My Mind? (SUR+DttP) 1230 (34/186)
3 (=) Gigantic (SUR+DttP+BSI) 1128 (22/183)
4 (=) Gouge Away (DOO+DttP) 987 (32/151)
5 (=) Hey (DOO+BBC+OTH) 975 (26/152)
6 (=) Monkey Gone To Heaven (DOO+DttP+BBC) 723 (12/136)
7 (=) Bone Machine (SUR+DttP+BSI) 647 (11/110)
8 (-1) Wave of Mutilation (DOO+DttP+BBC+BSI) 642 (7/124)
9 (+6) Here Comes Your Man (DOO+DttP) 618 (14/106)
10 (=) Velouria (BOS+DttP) 595 (12/103)
11 (+1) Alec Eiffel (TLM) 592 (8/104)
12 (-1) Caribou (PIL+DttP+BBC) 583 (6/100)
13 (=) Dig For Fire (BOS+DttP) 577 (9/108)
- (-4) No.13 Baby (DOO+BSI) 577 (12/94)
15 (-1) River Euphrates (SUR+BSI) 529 (17/89)
16 (+1) I Bleed (DOO) 492 (10/83)
17 (+1) Tame (DOO+DttP) 485 (8/88)
18 (-2) Subbacultcha (TLM+BBC) 482 (5/87)
19 (=) Cactus (SUR+BSI) 472 (12/71)
20 (=) Motorway to Roswell (TLM) 432 (9/79)
21 (+7) Allison (BOS) 398 (9/69)
22 (+3) Levitate Me (PIL+BBC) 385 (5/74)
23 (+1) Is She Weird? (BOS+BBC) 381 (8/70)
24 (-1) The Happening (BOS) 378 (6/75)
25 (-3) Bird Dream Of The Olympus Mons (TLM) 368 (5/65)
26 (-5) All Over the World (BOS) 367 (7/65)
27 (+2) U-Mass (TLM+DttP) 348 (1/69)
28 (-1) Head On (TLM) 341 (7/59)
29 (+1) Hang Wire (BOS) 340 (7/65)
30 (+9) The Holiday Song (PIL+DttP+BSI) 330 (5/59)
31 (=) Letter To Memphis (TLM+BBC) 325 (8/62)
32 (+3) I've Been Tired (PIL) 308 (6/54)
33 (-7) Nimrod's Son (PIL+DttP+BSI) 295 (6/58)
34 (-2) Planet of Sound (TLM+DttP) 287 (2/58)
- (=) Break My Body (SUR) 287 (2/50)
36 (+2) Isla De Encanta (PIL+BSI) 285 (4/53)
37 (=) Ana (BOS+BBC) 284 (6/51)
38 (-5) Vamos (PIL+SUR) 278 (3/54)
39 (-4) Dead (DOO+BBC) 276 (6/54)
40 (=) Mr. Grieves (DOO) 274 (4/48)
41 (+1) Rock Music (BOS) 242 (3/47)
42 (-1) Trompe Le Monde (TLM) 236 (6/49)
43 (+2) Into the White (BSI) 217 (3/39)
44 (+5) Broken Face (SUR) 212 (2/45)
45 (+1) Manta Ray (BBC+BSI) 200 (3/42)
46 (-3) Brick Is Red (SUR) 198 (2/38)
47 (+7) Tony's Theme (SUR) 193 (3/36)
48 (-1) Crackity Jones (DOO) 189 (2/37)
49 (+3) La La Love You (DOO) 187 (1/37)
50 (+1) Down to the Well (BOS+BBC+OTH) 182 (2/31)
51 (-3) Something Against You (SUR) 172 (4/34)
52 (-9) The Sad Punk (TLM) 166 (0/35)
53 (-4) D = R x T (TLM) 162 (0/29)
54 (-1) Ed Is Dead (PIL) 158 (1/33)
55 (+1) Cecilia Ann (BOS+DttP) 141 (1/25)
56 (-1) Oh My Golly! (SUR) 132 (2/25)
57 (+4) The Navajo Know (TLM) 115 (1/21)
58 (+2) Blown Away (BOS) 112 (1/25)
59 (-1) In Heaven (BSI+BBC) 111 (0/25)
60 (+2) Havalina (BOS) 104 (0/24)
61 (-2) Silver (DOO) 103 (1/24)
62 (-5) Dancing the Manta Ray (BSI) 91 (2/19)
63 (+1) There Goes My Gun (DOO+BBC) 88 (0/16)
64 (+5) Stormy Weather (BOS) 78 (0/21)
65 (-2) Evil Hearted You (BSI) 74 (1/13)
66 (=) Winterlong (BSI) 72 (1/16)
67 (+3) I'm Amazed (SUR) 68 (0/12)
68 (-3) Lovely Day (TLM) 64 (2/15)
- (+5) Bailey's Walk (BSI) 64 (2/12)
70 (+2) Palace of the Brine (TLM) 61 (0/17)
71 (-5) I've Been Waiting For You (BSI) 52 (2/10)
72 (-1) I Can't Forget (OTH) 51 (0/14)
- (+2) Weird At My School (BSI) 51 (0/13)
74 (-8) Space (I Believe In) (TLM) 48 (0/12)
75 (=) Santo (BSI) 44 (2/7)
76 (=) Born In Chicago (OTH) 37 (0/6)
77 (-1) Theme From Narc (BSI) 33 (0/9)
78 (+1) Rock A My Soul (OTH) 26 (0/6)
- (=) Make Believe (BSI) 26 (0/5)
80 (+3) Boom Chick a Boom (OTH) 23 (1/4)
81 (-1) The Thing (BSI) 20 (0/6)
82 (=) Wild Honey Pie (BBC) 18 (0/3)
83 (-2) Build High (BSI) 11 (0/5)
84 (=) Velvety (BSI) 6 (0/4)

Notes on rare songs (OTH):

To be exhaustive, Hang On To Your Ego, available on Rough Diamonds boot, could be added.

Some other perspectives to the results:

65 songs have been ranked 1st at least once!

TOP 5 / nb of times cited:

  1. Debaser (257)
  2. Where Is My Mind? (186)
  3. Gigantic (183)
  4. Hey (152)
  5. Gouge Away (151)

TOP 5 / nb of times ranked 1st:

  1. Debaser (48)
  2. Where Is My Mind? (34)
  3. Gouge Away (32)
  4. Hey (26)
  5. Gigantic (22)

TOP 5 / average nb of points (for songs cited at least 5x):

  1. Debaser (6.79)
  2. Cactus (6.65)
  3. Where Is My Mind? (6.61)
  4. Gouge Away (6.54)
  5. Hey (6.41)


PIXIES ALBUMS 452 votes

Results without "Come On Pilgrim" considered on its own (452 votes)

4 points when ranked 1st, then 3, 2, and 1.
Between parentheses, the number of times the album was ranked 1st.

  1. Doolittle: 1388 (191)
  2. SR (& PIL): 1265 (144)
  3. Bossanova: 954 (62)
  4. TLM: 934 (52)

Results considering "Come On Pilgrim" as a separate album (244 votes)

5 points when ranked 1st, then 4, 3, 2, and 1.
Between parentheses, the number of times the album was ranked 1st.

  1. Doolittle: 947 (95)
  2. Surfer Rosa: 851 (60)
  3. TLM: 658 (30)
  4. Bossanova: 635 (36)
  5. Pilgrim: 574 (21)

Ranking based on the average number of points per song

  1. Doolittle: 557.4
  2. Surfer Rosa: 426.6
  3. Pilgrim: 327.75
  4. Bossanova: 298.5
  5. TLM: 268.5

With the same calculation, "Death To The Pixies" compilation gets 668.3 points and "At The BBC" 377...


GROUPS 433 votes

3 points when ranked 1st, then 2 and 1.
Between parentheses, the number of times the group/artist was ranked 1st.
  1. Pixies: 1260 (406)
  2. Frank Black: 700 (15)
  3. Breeders: 630 (12)
Note: this is a PIXIES poll, hence the big difference with the other two.

186 people cited the Amps in their answer. Excluding the Pixies from the count, here are the results (there has been once a tie):

  1. Frank Black: 436 (104)
  2. Breeders: 413 (69)
  3. Amps: 272 (13)
108 people included the Martinis in their answer. They only have released two songs so far (Free on the Empire Records soundtrack, and Sunshine on the Nothing in Common compilation), but have been touring and have a demo tape (thanks to Ray for the informations).
  1. Frank Black: 362 (67)
  2. Breeders: 322 (31)
  3. Amps: 224 (6)
  4. Martinis: 153 (1)

ORIGINS OF CONTRIBUTIONS (if not contributors)

I thought it was interesting (at least funny) to determine where people contributed from. By having a look at e-mail addresses and contents of the answers, I can say that contributions originated from at least the following parts of the world:
Argentina
Australia
Belgium
Brazil
Canada
Chile
Croatia
Danemark
Ecuador
Estonia
Finland
France
Germany
Greece
Hong Kong 
Ireland
Israel
Italy
Malaysia
Mexico
Netherlands
New Zealand
Norway
Portugal
South Africa
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
UK
USA

Thanks again to everybody who did and will participate to this poll.

If you wish to contribute to this poll, just click HERE!



Last Updated 11-30-98